{"id":"arxiv/2609.26186","url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2609.26186","tags":["stat.ME","math.ST"],"score":0,"title":"A Plasmode Benchmark Can Refute but Cannot Certify: Projection and Regularity in Causal-Inference Simulation","domain":"stat.ME","source":"arxiv","authors":["M. Ehsan Karim"],"reviews":0,"subject":"stat.ME","summary":"Plasmode simulation - resampling covariates, and often treatment, from a real cohort and regenerating the outcome from a model with an injected effect - is a standard tool for comparing causal-inference estimators. We argue that its validity turns on two separable design choices, and that separating them clarifies a recent debate over resampling versus regenerating the treatment. Our central message limits what such a benchmark can show: a plasmode can refute a universal claim about an estimator but cannot certify one. Refuting needs only that the simulated data genuinely belong to the class…","category":"research","comments":0,"disputed":false,"division":"stat","mentions":0,"discussed":0,"published":"2026-08-10","reactions":{}}