{"id":"arxiv/2610.03843","url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2610.03843","tags":["hep-th","astro-ph.CO","hep-ph","physics.optics","quant-ph"],"score":0,"title":"Comment on ''Chiral electromagnetic surface waves on Chern-Simons interfaces'' Phys.Rev.D114(2026)L051903 and on arXiv:2606.12513 by N. Kaloper","domain":"hep-th","source":"arxiv","authors":["Igor Bandos","Bohdan Zvorskyi"],"reviews":0,"subject":"hep-th","summary":"We demonstrate that Maxwell electrodynamics interacting with a planar Chern-Simons interface does not have plane wave solutions localized on the interface. We re-examine the derivation of such waves presented by N. Kaloper in [Phys.Rev.D114(2026)L051903] and show that at an intermediate step certain terms were missed in an equation therein. Taking these terms into account changes the final conclusion of [Phys.Rev.D114(2026)L051903]. We also show that the method used in [arXiv:2606.12513 [hep-th]] to reproduce the same result is not consistent.","category":"research","comments":0,"disputed":false,"division":"physics","mentions":0,"discussed":0,"published":"2026-10-02","reactions":{}}