Id: arxiv/2611.21336 Url: https://arxiv.org/abs/2611.21336 Tags: physics.hist-ph, astro-ph.EP, math-ph Score: 0 Title: Why Cassini's Oval Could Not Replace Kepler's Ellipse? Domain: physics.hist-ph Source: arxiv Authors: Pascal Descamps Reviews: 0 Subject: physics.hist-ph Category: research Comments: 0 Disputed: false Division: physics Mentions: 0 Discussed: 0 Published: 2026-11-16 Page: https://delphi.science/r/arxiv/2611.21336 In the later seventeenth century, Kepler's ellipse was not yet accepted. Ward claimed that Boulliau's conic hypothesis amounted to a Ptolemaic equant at the ellipse's empty focus, and built his own model on it. Around 1675--1680, Giovanni Domenico Cassini proposed another curve, the ``oval'', a genus-1 quartic with no closed-form Kepler equation; yet its eccentric anomaly shares exactly the leading coefficient of Kepler's, and its empty focus is, for the Sun, 38 times closer to a true equant than the ellipse's. Dynamically, Binet's formula shows that the force producing the oval under the…